52-Week Movie Challenge: ‘A WALK IN THE CLOUDS’ (Week 15 – A Romance Film Set During WWII)
“Beauty aside, and this film is beautiful, it does have a real issue with Keanu’s performance... It’s wooden, it’s stale, and the chemistry he shares on screen with Aitana is not very believable.”
A WALK IN THE CLOUDS was a romantic drama film that was released in 1995, directed by Alfonso Arau, written by Robert Mark Kamen, Mark Miller, and Harvey Weitzman, and starring Keanu Reeves as Paul Sutton as well as Aitana Sánchez-Gijón as Victoria Aragón - and it's basically about this soft-hearted WWII veteran who stumbles upon a pregnant, unmarried woman terrified of her super traditional family, so he agrees to fake-marry her to save face, but then he predictably falls head over heels for her while hanging out at her family’s gorgeous, dramatic vineyard.
52-WEEK MOVIE CHALLENGE: WEEK #15 - A ROMANCE FILM SET DURING WORLD WAR II
Recently, I put up a poll on my YouTube channel asking the public for help in deciding this week’s prompt. I gave everyone four possible choices: 1996’s The English Patient, starring Ralph Fiennes; 2007’s Atonement, starring James McAvoy and Keira Knightley; 2016’s Allied, starring Brad Pitt and Marion Cotillard; and 1995’s A Walk in the Clouds, starring Keanu Reeves. Over 100 people voted in the poll, and the uncontested winner was undoubtedly A Walk in the Clouds with almost half of all votes. It was a lot more divisive of a poll than I thought it might be, and the movie I would have guessed won... only landed in third place. But the people have spoken. How is this Keanu Reeves period romance?
First and foremost, A Walk in the Clouds is gorgeous. It’s essentially a living painting. While watching, I had this feeling at the pit of my stomach that the graphic designer on the film also worked on What Dreams May Come. There’s a lot of mirroring aesthetics in both films that sometimes zoom out of this picturesque vineyard to show what looks like a painting. It’s beautiful, and only one other movie in recent memory did something similar, and it was undeniably What Dreams May Come. Lo and behold, I was right. The same visual effects company, Illusion Arts, founded by Bill Taylor and Syd Dutton, contributed specialized optical illusions, glass paintings, and matte shots to both What Dreams May Come and A Walk in the Clouds. Now... I’ve been able to pick certain signatures out of a crowd before. I’ve done it for director, writer, cinematographer, composer, and even casting director before... but this is the first time I’ve done it for a visual effects company, especially one I’d never even heard of before. Pretty crazy.
Truthfully, if I had to guess, the main reason a majority of people voted for A Walk in the Clouds was for its visuals, because as a movie past that, it’s mostly... fine? This wasn’t a film that received very many award nominations or wins. It did win Best Original Score at the Golden Globes, and the MTV Movie Awards nominated it for Best Kiss. Past that, Keanu Reeves received a nomination for Worst Actor at the Razzie Awards for the film... and honestly, with a romance film, if you’re receiving a Razzie nomination for worst acting, I think you have a major problem on your hands. At least half of the weight of a romance comes down to believing in the performance of the couple. If you don’t believe that, you won’t get sucked in; you won’t be swooning, and if you’re not swooning, the film has just lost half of its appeal with the romance angle. Beauty aside, and this film is beautiful, it does have a real issue with Keanu’s performance. This film was released just one year after Speed, but it feels much more in line with 1992’s Bram Stoker’s Dracula when it comes to Keanu Reeves and his ability to act. It’s not great here. It’s wooden, it’s stale, and the chemistry he shares on screen with Aitana Sánchez-Gijón is not very believable.
Aitana, while we are on her, is great by comparison. Her character is dreamy and has a story that feels very unique. She has a family dynamic with a vineyard that feels very different than a lot of other romance films. Her family, particularly her disapproving father, is really good, and it reminds me of the Meet the Parents stereotype when it comes to Keanu Reeves proving himself and the competitive nature between the two. That part’s great. But the entire movie really does revolve around the age-old fake relationship trope. Where it’s all, “Hey, I’ll pretend to be your husband! There’s no way I’ll catch any real feelings!” Which... everybody knows how those movies pan out.
One of my main complaints about the movie, other than maybe Keanu Reeves’s performance, is the period piece part of everything. As a movie that is set around World War II, I sometimes had a hard time buying into the era. Yes, everyone is wearing appropriate era-style clothing and hair. Yes, they had the right cars driving around. But none of this takes place in the war, for instance. He has returned home for the time being, and a majority of the movie takes place at this vineyard in the middle of nowhere with Keanu Reeves, who sells chocolate for a living... and aesthetically the movie looks like a painting. I think one of the downsides of a movie looking like a living painting is that it loses that 1940s aesthetic of a wartime setting. If I had to guess at what the movie feels more like, in terms of a setting, it is perhaps the 1960s, which makes a lot of sense. I think the 1940s and wartime are often associated with dull, muted colors for a depressing time in our lives, and the 1960s were associated with much brighter, vibrant, lively colors... like a painting.
At the end of the day, I’m glad I saw it. It was certainly an interesting film that felt more original with the vineyard storyline than I thought it would feel, with an aesthetic that is worth seeing, but the wooden acting hurt the chemistry... and the chemistry in a romance is everything.
Unbiased/Technical Score: 35/50 or 70%
Biased/Entertainment Score: 29/50 or 58%
Total Combined Score: 64/100 or 64% (3/5 on Letterboxd)





Discussion about this post